Results 1 to 13 of 13

Thread: Is medical research a democracy?

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    NC
    Posts
    8,903

    Is medical research a democracy?

    There have been many noises lately about whether there should be some credentials in order to post original science claims in a research section.

    Here are some relevant questions in my opinion...

    1. What are the legitimate purposes of the research section?
    2. What are some illegitimate purposes?
    3. Can lay people understand the research literature?
    4. Does it matter if nonsense is posted in the research section?
    5. Is emotion a legitimate reason to criticize researchers?


    Maybe anyone who is interested in what is going on in the research section can respond. Here are my answers...

    1. What are the legitimate purposes of the research section?

    In my opinion, the main legitimate purpose is to post relevant research in a form that is written for a lay audience.

    2. What are some illegitimate purposes?

    Some illegitimate purposes include:
    - alternative treatment purveyors trolling for innocent victims
    - lay people with obviously no training just expounding randomly

    3. Can lay people understand the research literature?

    Yes if they have relevant training. No if they don't. Nobody is born knowing this stuff and you can't learn it from one or several five minute google searches. It is highly unlikely that someone with no relevant training is going to contribute something valuable. Is it possible? Yes. Is it likely? No. Is it obvious when someone is expounding ignorantly? Yes (to those with science training). Will it be obvious to everyone? No, not to those with no science training.

    4. Does it matter if nonsense is posted in the research section?

    I think it does because when you have bunnies speaking nonsense to bunnies, there is always the danger that some innocent child will suffer.

    5. Is emotion a legitimate reason to criticize researchers?

    No. Do we see that often in this section? Yes by lay people.
    Last edited by Pooka1; 02-28-2014 at 01:11 PM.
    Sharon, mother of identical twin girls with scoliosis

    No island of sanity.

    Question: What do you call alternative medicine that works?
    Answer: Medicine


    "We are all African."

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    NC
    Posts
    8,903
    Revised list:

    1. Does it help to have people with no science training (i.e., alchemists) posting on chemistry fora?

    2. Does it help to have people with no science training (i.e., creationists) posting on biology fora?

    3. Does it help to have people with no history training (i.e., Holocaust deniers) posting on history fora?

    4. Does it help to have people with no science or medical training (i.e., lay parents and patients) posting IN THE RESEARCH SECTION holding forth on medical/scientific matters?

    5. Is emotion a legitimate reason to criticize researchers?
    Last edited by Pooka1; 02-28-2014 at 01:12 PM.
    Sharon, mother of identical twin girls with scoliosis

    No island of sanity.

    Question: What do you call alternative medicine that works?
    Answer: Medicine


    "We are all African."

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    2,755
    Quote Originally Posted by Pooka1 View Post
    Does it help to have people with no science training (i.e., alchemists) posting on chemistry fora?

    Does it help to have people with no science training (i.e., creationists) posting on biology fora?

    Does it help to have people with no history training (i.e., Holocaust deniers) posting on history fora?

    Does it help to have people with no science or medical training (i.e., lay parents and patients) posting on medical issue fora for lay people?
    To the last question, I will say yes, if they have a medically related experience to share. They should be able to say this or that happened to me, OR my family history is this or that. Then they can state if it fits into the "known" medical science and ask a professional why or why not. It's okay to post ideas, too. It's NOT okay to try to back them up with published journals so that they can pick and choose.

    I can imagine someone saying this or that journal said.... Does this mean?....
    That's how people learn. But, this back and forth hypothesizing (not theorizing) can be VERY misleading to people. Then there becomes a "following of believers" because a person sounds convincing, when in actuality they are talking smooth, sugar-coated rubbish.

    That's exactly how Hitler came into power. And for those that don't know, the good old USA had concentration camps during WWII, while at the same time condemning Germany for having them. Albeit, Germans were starving, doing horrific medical experimentations, and executing those in their camps. The USA had "relocation camps" for ALL Japanese Americans, whether they were born here or not. WOW! You don't read that in High School History books!
    Be happy!
    We don't know what tomorrow brings,
    but we are alive today!

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    NC
    Posts
    8,903
    Quote Originally Posted by rohrer01 View Post
    To the last question, I will say yes, if they have a medically related experience to share. They should be able to say this or that happened to me, OR my family history is this or that. Then they can state if it fits into the "known" medical science and ask a professional why or why not. It's okay to post ideas, too. It's NOT okay to try to back them up with published journals so that they can pick and choose.
    Oh hey I should have worded that better. The testimonials are so valuable. I mean to limit it to the research section and comments about the scientific literature. I'll fix that. And I also forgot to include my fifth question.

    I can imagine someone saying this or that journal said.... Does this mean?....
    That's how people learn. But, this back and forth hypothesizing (not theorizing) can be VERY misleading to people. Then there becomes a "following of believers" because a person sounds convincing, when in actuality they are talking smooth, sugar-coated rubbish.

    That's exactly how Hitler came into power. And for those that don't know, the good old USA had concentration camps during WWII, while at the same time condemning Germany for having them. Albeit, Germans were starving, doing horrific medical experimentations, and executing those in their camps. The USA had "relocation camps" for ALL Japanese Americans, whether they were born here or not. WOW! You don't read that in High School History books!
    Great points.
    Sharon, mother of identical twin girls with scoliosis

    No island of sanity.

    Question: What do you call alternative medicine that works?
    Answer: Medicine


    "We are all African."

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    2,755
    Question 5. Emotion isn't a reason to criticize anyone. Spouses do it to each other. Parents and children do it. "Friends" do it. Strangers do it. Remember the music videos by Dr. Weiss? That provoked quite an emotional response. So, I guess that wouldn't be a reason to criticize his work, either.

    BTW, I looked at his webpage recently and he seems to be working mostly as a PM&R doctor (Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation) with kids who've had fusion, along with his bracing, of course. PM&R is a legitimate field of medicine. He would be helping those kids get back on their feet by managing limitations from their surgeries and helping medically with pain control.

    My PM&R doctor helps with pain management and does EMG Botox, trigger point therapy and other things with other people. They try to use non-surgical approaches (not non-medical) to help the patient avoid surgery, but will refer to a surgeon when needed.
    Be happy!
    We don't know what tomorrow brings,
    but we are alive today!

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    NC
    Posts
    8,903
    As far as I can tell, Weiss may have had surgical training but didn't operate as surgeon much (pardon that pun). He tried to make Schroth work for many years and then moved on.
    Sharon, mother of identical twin girls with scoliosis

    No island of sanity.

    Question: What do you call alternative medicine that works?
    Answer: Medicine


    "We are all African."

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •